I'm leaving a 5 star review because the problems I experience are "user related" and not a problem with the product. :) I'm not used to wearing liquid liner so I'm still trying to figure out how to apply correctly. I also wear glasses so I have a hard time seeing clear enough to apply it without my glasses! Product-wise though, it's great. Nice color, slides on nice and stays put all day. (And comes off nicely at nice.)

So, glad it's back in stock. Love that the wand is shorter, it's easier to use when you need to get closer to the mirror to put it on. Glides on super smooth.

The new wand makes all the different. I like how this is basically water resistant and it’s easy to apply a thin line.

I am still learning liquid eyeliner, so it's definitely a process- but the applicator is concise and I don't have to worry about smudging it. It'll take some more practice but the actual liner is beautiful. It stays on ALL day - and is even a little difficult to remove. I look forward to practicing more until I get it down, and then this will be a regular in my lineup.