I'm so excited that you're looking into building a Pretty Forever Palette. Based on the looks you liked on Instagram as well as the shades you currently wear on your page, here are some recommendations!
I would suggest any of these shades for your eyeshadow. Erin, Cabernet, Stainless, Stella, Sugar, Sweet Tea, Coco and Colette. You would also probably love using our Stiletto for eyeliner (I included my favorite brush for eyeliner here too)! I think you would also enjoy our brow products - these also fit conveniently into your palette. There are two products, a brow powder & a brow pomade, for you I would select the deep brown shade.
For your cheeks and lips, our Pretty Paints are a mutli-use cream lip & cheek product that fit wonderfully in the lower compartment of the palette. The shades Krea, Jaci and Miranda would be beautiful on you. Pretty Paints are a bit more shear on the lips, so I would also suggest our XOXO & Bombshell Vegan Shea Butter Lipstick.
If you would also like some pressed options for your cheeks, Maya Bronze, Shana Bronze, Sam Blush, Sierra Blush, and December Blush would pair so well with your complexion.
For the Instagram looks you liked those included Merlot and Breanne which are loose eyeshadows. Those are also some of my favorites because they apply beautifully wet, but they come in a jar & would not fit into your Pretty Forever Palette. I included them here for you to peek at too, though!
Hopefully these suggestions help you build your dream palette! Let me know if you have any other shade requests (want help narrowing it down even more) or need additional help with any of our products!