My good friend gave this to me for my birthday, just a few days ago. It was so funny because I was just getting lectured by someone else a few days earlier on how I too young for my eyes to be so puffy and that I really should have the surgery done.. I told her about the eye serum I went home and I used it that day and evening and next morning.. when I saw my friend, who was insistent on me getting surgery, she was amazed me by the difference, there already was in just three applications.. I have tried many things, but this has been the best product I have used for my under eye eyes so far.. as far as wearing it with make up and eyeliner I find that if I wake up early and I am able to apply at a good hour and a half before any make up and I put a foundation around my eyes, I have no issues until the end of the day.. and that’s after chasing a toddler around for 12 hours, so that’s expected anyway